Are you searching for the best way to test your latest software and not sure whether test scripting or exploratory testing fits the bill?
Lately, the latter has become the darling of agile development. However, test scripts have proven their effectiveness over time.
As a software engineer or test manager, it is up to you to compare the two and decide.
Weve gone ahead and done the work for you. Read on for a concise comparison of these two popular methods to help you decide which is best for you.
A test script is a complex set of instructions that testers must follow to see if the desired outcome is achieved.
Provided intensive preparation is done, this method should cover all the bases when it comes to uncovering software errors. It is so detailed that you could even get a machine to do it for you.
What is exploratory testing used for then? This procedure relies on the experience and intuition of the testers to root out errors for themselves. They are not provided with the expected outcomes in advance.
In this way, off script testing has the benefit of creating scenarios that the script writer may have overlooked.
Comparative studies have proven that exploratory testing exposes more errors faster than test scripting does.
The following is revealed when taking the most important testing factors into account:
This is imperative for effective exploratory testing. This is not a factor when the rigid procedures of scripted testing are employed.
Test dependencies are better managed with test scripting. Unscripted testing relies on the skill sets of the testers to manage these.
A high level of documentation and a significant lead time are required for scripted tests. Exploratory testing requires neither, provided domain knowledge is adequate.
When it comes to efficiency, it is time-consuming and laborious to create detailed scripts. There is no comparison with the speedy off-the-cuff nature of unscripted testing.
This provides no clear and measurable coverage. It relies on the testers to document their findings. Scripted tests involve detailed, formal record keeping.
Scripted tests formally verify the results against set specifications. Unscripted testing is based on the testers expectations and domain knowledge.
High-risk areas can be covered in minute detail with scripted tests. There is a chance these may be overlooked by exploratory testers.
Tests can be reproduced accurately with test scripting. Only defects can be reproduced with the less formal approach.
When deadlines are looming and you need to test the major aspects of your software quickly, exploratory testing is the answer. It is a cost effective method if your project is fairly straightforward, such as a simple informational website.
Often it is a good idea to do complex testing at first and then follow up with unscripted testing. Exploratory testing closely mimics end-user interaction with the software. It also allows for the vagaries of human interaction.
As for who wins? You do. You have the benefit of selecting from two proven tactics for each stage of your software development.
Looking to save money? There are ways to leverage great technology without burning a hole in your wallet. Here are some safe, secure options all of them free that can help make your computer more productive, useful and fun: * Firefox Browser: (www.GetFireFox.com) Get onto the Internet with this alternative to Windows Internet Explorer that is compatible....read more
You might be surprised at some of the things you can pick up for a great price at your local drugstore. If youre in need of any of the items below, head to your nearest 24-hour pharmacy. Milk Milk is often put on special offer in drugstores. These deals make it into a loss leader meaning that its low price is used to entice shoppers....read more
The art of link building is not learned overnight. It takes multiple tries to see results from mastering your content. Weve established our own approach to growing adult website traffic through the power of link building. Are you interested in finding out how you can spice up your website with some much-needed sex appeal? Read on to....read more
Its a routine homeowners know theyre supposed to perform twice a year. But when one of those times for checking the health of their roof happens to coincide with the start of sharply colder weather if not worse surprises from Mother Nature well, who wants to be outside climbing a ladder for a birds-eye view? Turns out that while even a quick roof-check is....read more
If youre like a lot of gamblers, you can relate to this scenario: You smash it at the table, collect your winnings, and running high on adrenaline and the sheer thrill that comes with beating the house, wonder to yourself, Is making a living gambling possible? It is, and even more so when you have insider information on your side. You see, to....read more
We love watching a great football match. There is nothing like the drama and excitement of crafty competitors leaving every ounce of effort out on the football pitch during a match. Football is like no other sport for the excitement of the crowd too. Part of the thrill of watching a match is hearing the roar of the crowd. More than most sports....read more